Deals and Coupons
Fresh Homemade Pizza
Cheese Pizza With One Topping
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$10.25
Gluten Free Pizza
10" gluten free crust add your favorite toppings
$13.99
Cauliflower Crust Pizza
$13.99
Individual Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza,
$5.99
Specialty Pizza
Taco Pizza
Homemade sauce, re-fried beans, taco meat, onions, Colby cheese, lettuce and tomato
$13.99
Chicken BLT Pizza
Salad dressing, chicken, mozzarella cheese, Bacon, lettuce and tomato
$12.99
Southwest Chicken Pizza
Five star sauce mixed with salsa, mozzarella cheese, chicken, green pepper, onions, mushrooms and hot pepper flakes
$13.99
Bacon Cheese Burger Pizza
Ketchup,mustard,salad dressing,Colby cheese,ground beef, onions, dill pickles, bacon, lettuce and tomato
$13.99
Boom Boom Taco Pizza
Boom boom sauce, taco meat, Colby cheese, onions, re-fried beans,lettuce and tomato
$13.99
Penny Deluxe Pizza
$13.99
Star Deluxe Pizza
$13.99
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni, ham, bacon and sausage
$13.99
BBQ Chicken Pizza
$13.99
Jimmy Mac Burger Pizza
Jimmy Mac Sauce, Colby cheese , pickle , onion, lettuce
$15.99
Jalapeno Pizza
Comes with cream cheese, pickles, jalapenos, bacon, mozzarella cheese no sauces.
$15.99
Mac & Cheese Pizza
Garlic sauce, Mac & Cheese , bacon and Colby cheese
$15.99
Specials
16" w/ 2 Toppings & 10" cheesy sticks
$28.99
14'' 1 Topping Pizza Special
$11.99
12'' 2 Toppings Pizza & Small Cheesy Sticks Special
$16.99
Appetizers
Mozzarella Breadsticks
Oven baked with garlic sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$9.99
Regular Breadsticks
$7.99
Boneless Wings
$10.99
Bone In Wings
Breaded and delicious bone in chicken wings
$15.99
Jalapeno Poppers
10 Juicy jalapeno poppers breaded and filled with cheese and fried to golden perfection.
$13.99
French Fries
Our delicious French fries are deep-fried 'till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior.
$5.99
Deep fried mozzarella sticks
6 cheesy mozzarella sticks with pizza sauce.
$11.99
Sauces
$1.75
Maple Cinnamon Bites
Sprinkled with maple and cinnamon. Tossed in lots of melted Butter and topped with Butter cream frosting.
$8.99
Spicy Cheese Curds
Half pound of really spicy cheese curds. side of ranch dressing
$11.99
Ranch Flavor Cheese Curds
8 ounces of ranch flavor cheese curds w\ ranch to dip them in.
$11.99
Specialty Sticks
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sticks
Topped with Ranch sauce, mozzarella cheese, Chicken and Bacon.
$13.99
Chicken Bacon BBQ Sticks
Topped with BBQ sauce, Mozzarella cheese, Chicken and Bacon.
$13.99
Pickle Ranch Sticks
Topped with Ranch sauce, Mozzarella cheese and lots of Pickles. Perfect for the Ranch and Pickle LOVERS.
$11.99
Pepperoni Bacon Garlic Sticks
$13.99
Pickle Bacon Ranch Sticks
$13.99
Pickle Bacon Garlic Sticks
$13.99
Pepperoni Ranch Sticks
Pepperoni, mozzarella cheese and ranch sauce
$9.99
Jalapeno Cheesy sticks
Garlic butter crust smothered in mozzarella cheese topped with Jalapenos
$11.99
Salads
Chicken Taco Salad
Onions, green peppers, homemade taco meat, nacho chips, Colby cheese, lettuce & tomato.
$13.99
Beef Taco Salad
Onions, green peppers, homemade taco, nacho chips, Colby cheese, lettuce & tomato.
$12.99
Chicken Pineapple Salad
Chicken, pineapple, lettuce, Colby cheese & cashews.
$9.99
Chef Salad
Onions, green peppers, lettuce, chicken, ham, tomato, & mozzarella cheese.
$9.99
Deluxe Salad
Lettuce, onions, green peppers, ham, chicken, bacon, tomato & mozzarella cheese.
$9.99
Roasted Chicken Almond Salad
Lettuce toasted almonds rice noodles green pepper onions & roasted chicken.
$9.99
Jimmy Mac Burger Salad
Lettuce,pickle,onion, mozzarella cheese, bacon, cooked beef and Jimmy Mac Sauce: The piece de resistance, this special sauce is the secret ingredient that brings all the components together. Creamy, tangy, and slightly sweet, Jimmy Mac Sauce is the finishing touch that completes the salad.
$9.99
Calzones
Calzone
Pizza dough folded, with sauce, mozzarella cheese.
$9.99
Baked Subs
Regular Sub
Pepperoni, salad dressing, ham, mozzarella cheese & lettuce.
$8.99
Super Deluxe Sub
Salad dressing, pepperoni, ham, mushroom, onion, mozzarella cheese & lettuce.
$9.99
Ham & Cheese Sub
Ham, salad dressing, mozzarella cheese, lettuce.
$8.99
Turkey Sub
Turkey, mozzarella cheese, lettuce, salad dressing. Chips & Pickle on the side
$9.99
Vegetarian Sub
Salad dressing, mozzarella cheese, onions, green olives, green peppers, mushrooms, lettuce. Chips & Pickle on the side
$8.99
Pizza Sub
Pizza sauce, ham, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, mozzarella cheese, sausage. Chips & Pickle on the side
$9.99
Meatball Sub
Meat sauce, meatballs, mozzarella cheese. Chips & Pickle on the side
$9.99
Club Sub
Salad dressing, chicken, ham, lettuce, bacon, tomato, pepperoni, mozzarella cheese. Chips & Pickle on the side
$9.99
BLT Sub
Salad dressing, bacon, mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomato. Chips & Pickle on the side
$9.99
Chicken Deluxe Sub
Salad dressing, chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mozzarella cheese. Chips & Pickle on the side
$9.99
Italian Sub
Italian dressing, ham, pepperoni, salami, banana peppers, mozzarella cheese, lettuce. Chips & pickle on the side
$9.99
Jimmy Mac Burger Sub
Jimmy Mac sauce, beef, pickle, onions,lettuce, cheese on a sub bun
$9.99
Wraps
Crispy BBQ Wrap
BBQ sauce , mozzarella cheese, crispy chicken, Bacon and lettuce
$13.99
Spicy Chicken Wrap
Crispy chicken, Bacon, lettuce, mozzarella cheese,Bacon and Franks hot sauce.
$13.99
Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap
$13.99
Chicken Boom Boom Wrap
Boom boom sauce,Bacon,mozzarella cheese, crispy chicken and lettuce
$13.99
Pickle BLT Wrap
Salad dressing, mozzarella cheese,pickle, bacon, lettuce and tomato
$12.99
Turkey Wrap
Turkey, mozzarella cheese, Bacon and lettuce
$13.99
Vegetarian Wrap
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, green olives and melted cheese.
$13.99
Jimmy Mac Burger Wrap
Beef, pickle, onions, lettuce and Jimmy Mac sauce
$13.99
Pasta
Lasagna
Homemade lasagna smothered in our homemade meat sauce topped with mozzarella cheese. Dinner sticks or garlic toast on the side
$13.99
Baked Spaghetti & Meatballs
Spaghetti topped with homemade meat sauce and meatballs, smothered with mozzarella cheese baked in the oven. Dinner sticks or garlic toast on the side
$13.99
Mac and Cheese
Papa Jim's homemade Mac & Cheese. Topped with BBQ sauce and bacon. Add pulled pork or Chicken and you have yourself ONE DELICIOUS MEAL. Comes with a 12" loaf of garlic toast.
$13.99
Mexican Dishes
Meat & Bean Burrito
Smothered in our homemade burrito sauce, Colby cheese, spicy ground beef, re fried beans lettuce & tomato, nacho chips on the side
$13.99
All Chicken Burrito
Smothered in our homemade burrito sauce, Colby cheese, lettuce &tomato, nacho chips on the side
$13.99
All Bean Burrito
Smothered in our homemade burrito sauce, re-fried beans, Colby cheese, lettuce &tomato, nacho chips on the side
$13.99
All Beef Burrito
Smothered in our homemade burrito sauce, spicy beef, Colby cheese, lettuce &tomato, nacho chips on the side
$13.99
Chicken & Bean Burrito
Smothered in our homemade burrito sauce, chicken, re-fried beans, Colby cheese, lettuce &tomato, nacho chips on the side
$13.99
Taco bowl.
Baked flour tortilla shell with beans , meat Colby cheese , lettuce and tomatoes. Chips,salsa and sour cream on the side.
$9.99
Chips & Cheese
Nacho chips smothered in Colby cheese.
$8.99
Chips & Cheese Deluxe
Chips, spicy beef, onion, green peppers, Colby cheese, and tomatoes.
$11.99
Papa Jim Cookies
Maple Cinna Bites
$8.99
Chocolatte
contains peanuts and Milk
$3.00
Butter Pecan cheese cake. Topped with a drizzle of chocolate and caramel
$4.99
Beverages
Soda
$3.95
Penny's Five Star Pizza
Support local businesses by eating local. Enjoy the best pizza in Lake Odessa like the locals do. Lake Odessa residents have made Penny's Five Star Pizza one of the most popular pizzerias in the area. Maybe it will become a favorite of yours, too! Some of the top dishes in Lake Odessa are served at local pizzerias. Expand your horizons with delicious options like sandwiches, salads, calzones, and more. Get Cheese Pizza with One Topping to see why it's so well-loved by locals and visitors alike. One taste and you'll see why it's so popular. Add to your meal with french fries. It's a good way to sample everything Penny's Five Star Pizza has to offer. Partnered with Slice since 2019, this restaurant has been a staple of the community for years. Try the food and see why they've remained popular with locals. Take home your pizza with curbside pickup. It's never been easier to grab a pizza whenever you feel the urge. You can make your meal easier on your wallet with deals from Penny's Five Star Pizza. Try something delicious at an affordable price! Pay by credit card. Stay updated on what's new at Penny's Five Star Pizza via social media.
Full Hours